Why Can Convicted Criminals Refuse to Attend Sentencing?

A fictional, anonymous male prisoner in a British courtroom, photographed from behind, wearing ordinary dark clothing. Two prison officers stand nearby. In the background is an empty courtroom dock, symbolising the convicted offenders who refuse to attend sentencing.

If a defendant can be brought to court throughout a criminal trial, why should attending sentencing suddenly become a matter of choice?

Why Should a Convicted Criminal Be Allowed to Miss the Final Day in Court?

Opinion | TopNews23.net | 17 November 2026

The recent trial and sentencing of Russell Brand at Southwark Crown Court raises an interesting question about the consistency of our criminal justice system.

On Thursday 5 November 2026, Brand was convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault following a four-week trial. He was remanded in custody and returned to court on Monday 9 November, when he was sentenced to ten years and six months in prison.

During the sentencing hearing, the four women’s Victim Personal Statements were read to the court. Brand was present to hear the proceedings before being returned to custody.

His attendance was an ordinary part of the court process. There was no publicly reported refusal to attend, nor any reported difficulty bringing him before the judge.

And that raises a question.

Why Should Sentencing Be Any Different?

Throughout a criminal trial, defendants are expected to attend court. Where they are held in custody, arrangements are made to transport them to court, escort them into the courtroom and return them to custody afterwards.

This happens routinely across the country.

Prison officers, court security staff and the judiciary manage these arrangements as part of the normal administration of justice.

Yet we have repeatedly heard of convicted murderers and other serious offenders refusing to attend their sentencing hearings, sometimes leaving victims’ families to deliver their statements without the offender present.

Why?

What has fundamentally changed between the previous day of court proceedings and the final hearing?

The defendant is the same person. The prison officers have the same responsibilities. The court has the same security arrangements.

The only significant difference is that the defendant has now been convicted.

Why should a guilty verdict change the obligation to attend court?

A Question of Procedure, Not Punishment

This is not an argument for treating prisoners more harshly or denying them their legal rights.

It is about applying a consistent procedure throughout the administration of justice.

If a defendant can be brought before the court to hear evidence, answer charges and receive a verdict, there should ordinarily be no procedural distinction when that same defendant is required to hear the sentence.

Of course, there may be exceptional circumstances involving genuine medical concerns, violence or an identifiable threat to safety.

But those circumstances should be established rather than assumed.

The possibility that a convicted offender may become uncooperative does not, in itself, explain why the ordinary arrangements for court attendance should cease to apply.

What About the Victims?

For victims and their families, sentencing is often the culmination of a long and painful legal process.

They may have spent months or years waiting for justice.

Some have endured difficult cross-examination, repeated court appearances and the emotional burden of recounting deeply distressing experiences.

Their Victim Personal Statements provide an opportunity to explain how the crime has affected their lives.

It seems extraordinary that, after everything victims have been required to endure, the convicted offender might be absent simply because they refuse to attend.

There is no guarantee that an offender will show remorse or even pay attention. The law cannot force genuine understanding or regret.

But physical attendance is a different matter.

The court should not automatically surrender control over its proceedings because an offender decides not to cooperate.

Parliament Has Recognised the Problem

The Victims and Courts Act 2026 introduced new provisions allowing Crown Court judges to order convicted offenders held in custody to attend sentencing.

The legislation also provides for reasonable force, where necessary and proportionate, to bring adult offenders into the courtroom, subject to the relevant provisions being brought into force.

This is an acknowledgement that allowing offenders to avoid sentencing can undermine the experience of victims and public confidence in the justice system.

However, the existence of legal powers does not entirely resolve the underlying question of consistency.

Why should special intervention be necessary to achieve what is ordinarily expected throughout the trial?

Surely the starting position should be that attendance at sentencing is part of the normal court process, with exceptions justified by specific circumstances.

The Russell Brand Example

Russell Brand’s case illustrates how the process can operate.

He was convicted, remanded in custody, returned to court for sentencing, heard the proceedings and was taken back into custody.

There is no suggestion that Brand attempted to avoid his sentencing hearing. His case is not an example of an offender refusing to attend.

It is an example of the ordinary court process functioning as expected.

And that is precisely why it raises a wider question.

If this is how the criminal justice system routinely operates, why should another convicted offender’s refusal be enough to interrupt the same procedure?

Justice Should Be Consistent Until the Very End

A criminal trial does not end with the jury’s verdict. Sentencing remains an essential part of the judicial process.

The public expects the courts to administer justice consistently, fairly and safely.

Victims should be entitled to expect the same.

There will always be exceptional circumstances where compelling attendance is unsafe or inappropriate. Those decisions must remain with the court and be based on the circumstances of the individual case.

But the mere fact that someone has been convicted should not turn court attendance from an ordinary obligation into a personal preference.

If the justice system can bring a defendant before a judge throughout the trial, it should ordinarily be able to do so when that judge delivers the sentence.

The question is not whether the convicted offender wishes to attend.

The question is why the final day of justice should be treated differently from every day that came before it.

Sources and Further Reading

Category: Society
Previous Post
Piddington Protest: Calls to Leave ECHR & Enforce Migrant Detention